Master Beryl and Allucia Citrus Relationship Analysis: From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Season 2

If there is one relationship in From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman that keeps catching my attention, it is the one between Beryl Gardenant and Allucia Citrus.

On paper, they are an incredibly strange match. Beryl is a 45-year-old countryside sword instructor who still seems genuinely confused whenever someone calls him a master swordsman. Allucia is a 25-year-old Knight Commander, an accomplished warrior, and one of the most respected people in the kingdom.

Yet whenever these two are together, the entire dynamic changes.

Allucia can command knights, handle dangerous situations, and carry herself like royalty. Put Beryl in front of her, though, and suddenly that composed commander starts behaving much more like the student who never quite stopped looking up to her old teacher.

And honestly? That contrast is one of my favorite things about the anime.

Their Relationship Started With Respect, Not Romance

Before talking about romance, I think it is important to understand why Allucia became so attached to Beryl in the first place.

Years before the main story, Allucia trained under Beryl at his small countryside dojo. At that point, she was simply a talented young student with enormous potential. Beryl, meanwhile, treated her like another pupil who needed guidance.

The funny part is that Beryl never really understood how extraordinary his own swordsmanship was.

Allucia did.

She saw the difference between Beryl and ordinary swordsmen long before the rest of the world caught up. His teaching gave her the foundation she needed to become the warrior and commander she eventually became.

For Allucia, Beryl wasn’t simply someone who taught her sword techniques.

He was the person who shaped her entire idea of what a great swordsman should be.

That makes their reunion much more meaningful than a simple “old teacher meets former student” scenario.

Why Allucia Wants Beryl Close to Her

One of the most entertaining parts of the story is the way Allucia brings Beryl to the capital.

Officially, there is an excellent reason for it. Beryl’s skills can benefit the Liberion Order of Knights, and having someone of his ability involved in training is obviously valuable.

But let’s be honest: Allucia has personal reasons too.

She doesn’t want Beryl to spend the rest of his life hiding away in a tiny rural dojo while everyone else remains unaware of what he can actually do.

More importantly, she wants him in her life.

This is where I think Allucia’s character becomes much more interesting than the typical anime love interest. She isn’t sitting around waiting for Beryl to magically figure out her feelings. She actively creates opportunities to spend time with him and repeatedly makes her intentions increasingly difficult to ignore.

Beryl’s response?

Usually something along the lines of:

“She respects me as her former teacher.”

No, Beryl.

That’s not what’s happening.

Beryl’s Biggest Problem Isn’t Allucia—It’s Himself

I don’t think Beryl is deliberately rejecting Allucia.

His problem is that he genuinely cannot imagine why someone like her would fall for someone like him.

There are several reasons for this.

• He still sees Allucia as his former student. In his mind, the young girl who trained at his dojo never completely disappeared.
• He severely underestimates himself. Beryl considers his abilities fairly ordinary despite repeatedly doing things that should make everyone around him question reality.
• He is uncomfortable with attention. The idea that a powerful young woman could seriously want to marry him simply doesn’t fit his understanding of himself.

And this is why their romantic tension works so well for me.

If Beryl were simply pretending not to notice Allucia’s feelings, it would become frustrating very quickly. Instead, his obliviousness actually feels connected to his personality.

He doesn’t think he’s good enough.

That makes his eventual realization potentially much more satisfying.

The Season 2 Duel Says a Lot About Them

One of the moments I was most interested in was the long-awaited confrontation between Beryl and Allucia after years apart.

For Allucia, this wasn’t just a casual spar.

She wanted to see how far she had progressed—and, naturally, she wanted to stand opposite the man who had taught her everything she knew about the sword.

She had become an exceptional fighter in her own right.

And then Beryl did what Beryl always does.

He reminded everyone that his idea of “being pretty good with a sword” is completely detached from reality.

The duel is important because it isn’t simply about determining who is stronger. There is a huge emotional component underneath it.

Allucia wants recognition from the person whose opinion matters most to her.

Beryl, meanwhile, still sees himself as the teacher watching one of his former students grow.

That difference in perspective is basically their entire relationship in miniature.

Season 2 Makes Allucia’s Jealousy Much More Obvious

If the early story was about establishing Allucia’s feelings, Season 2 is much more interested in showing what happens when she has competition.

And there is a lot of competition.

Beryl has accumulated several talented women around him during his adventures, including former students and powerful figures who clearly have their own attachment to him.

Surena is particularly important here.

Then there is Lucy, whose relationship with Beryl creates a completely different kind of tension. Lucy’s maturity and confidence make her feel like a particularly interesting alternative to Allucia.

Personally, I think these rivalries make the story more entertaining rather than distracting from it.

Allucia is incredibly composed when dealing with almost anyone else.

But when another woman gets too close to Beryl?

That composure starts disappearing.

And watching the terrifying Knight Commander become jealous over her former teacher is honestly one of the funniest recurring elements in the series.

Beryl and Allucia Compared

The interesting thing is that neither character really needs to become someone else.

Allucia doesn’t need to become less confident.

Beryl doesn’t need to suddenly turn into a smooth romantic hero.

The real development is about Beryl learning to see himself the way other people already see him.

Is Allucia Actually the Best Match for Beryl?

This is where I think fans can have a genuinely interesting debate.

If we’re judging the relationship purely by chemistry, Allucia has a huge advantage. Their history gives them an emotional connection that nobody else can easily replicate.

She knows where Beryl came from.

She knows what he taught her.

She understands how incredible his swordsmanship actually is.

And, perhaps most importantly, she wants Beryl himself—not some legendary version of him created by his reputation.

On the other hand, I completely understand why some fans prefer the idea of Beryl with someone closer to his own stage of life, such as Lucy.

The teacher-student history also makes the Allucia pairing complicated. Even though Allucia is an adult in the present story, Beryl’s memories of her as his student create a psychological barrier that isn’t easy to erase.

That’s precisely why I don’t expect their relationship to move at lightning speed.

Where to Read Katainaka no Ossan Kensei ni Naru Web Novel Online for Free

What Makes Their Romance Work

For me, the best part of the Beryl and Allucia relationship isn’t the question of whether they will eventually become a couple.

It’s how long it takes Beryl to understand what everyone else already knows.

Allucia’s feelings are hardly a secret.

The audience can see them.

The other characters can see them.

The people around Beryl can practically see them from another continent.

Beryl?

Still thinking she just really appreciates his teaching.

That running joke could become annoying in another series, but here it works because it connects directly to Beryl’s biggest character flaw: his inability to recognize his own worth.

His swordsmanship, confidence, social position, and romantic prospects all suffer from the same problem.

He simply doesn’t believe he’s particularly special.

And Allucia is one of the people determined to prove him wrong.

My Take on Beryl and Allucia

I don’t think the appeal of this relationship comes from some straightforward “master and student fall in love” fantasy.

It’s much more about two people who changed each other’s lives without realizing how deeply that connection would eventually matter.

Beryl gave Allucia the foundation to become the warrior she is today.

Allucia, in return, is one of the people responsible for dragging Beryl out of the quiet life where he was content to underestimate himself forever.

That’s a surprisingly wholesome foundation for a romance.

Whether the anime eventually makes Beryl and Allucia officially canon is another question. I wouldn’t expect a sudden confession and wedding to appear overnight. Their story has always been built around gradual emotional development, and Beryl has a lot of psychological baggage to work through first.

But if Season 2 has made one thing clear, it’s this:

Allucia isn’t giving up.

And considering how terrible Beryl is at recognizing romantic signals, she may need all the patience in the world.

For now, I’m perfectly happy watching the chaos unfold. The sword fights are great, Beryl’s absurdly humble reactions never stop being funny, and Allucia’s increasingly obvious attempts to get closer to him give the series an extra layer of comedy and emotional tension.

If Beryl eventually realizes that his former student isn’t looking at him like a master anymore, I suspect the payoff will be worth the wait.

Because sometimes the strongest swordsman in the room is also the last person to realize he’s been loved all along.